Why evidence doesn't work on atheists

Why did Thomas doubt the resurrection? Didn't he have evidence, trustworthy accounts, and a history with Jesus that should have led him to trust the resurrection? Is it possible that choice is an element of unbelief?

Find a church here: https://locator.lcms.org/church

Discord Link to multi-denominational Christian Server (if you join up, be sure to say "Hi" when you find me!) : Discord.gg/Christian

Are you in Tucson, do you need a faithful Lutheran (LCMS) church? Come by and visit, leave me a comment and I can give directions!