Name: BIOLOGY is for BIGOTS
Uploaded: 2023-08-01T17:00:00+00:00
Duration: 50 min 7 s
Description: At Flinders Station in Melbourne, Australia, Peter Boghossian presented the claim, “Gender is different from sex.” The ensuing discussion drew a crowd of onlookers. Midway through, a man disrupted the

2 years ago

525

At Flinders Station in Melbourne, Australia, Peter Boghossian presented the claim, “Gender is different from sex.” The ensuing discussion drew a crowd of onlookers. Midway through, a man disrupted the conversation and compared women’s free speech to Nazism.

Two female passersby and Richard from Common Ground Conversations participated in the SSE exercise. The women presented similar viewpoints about gender identity, both proposing that the subjective feeling of gender outweighs objective standards regarding anatomy, genetics, or hormonal profile. One woman stated that a doctor should know a patient’s “sex assigned at birth”; in every other case, biology is irrelevant.

Richard asserts that there are important differences between sex and gender identity, citing concern for women’s safety in shelters, prisons, changing rooms, and athletic competitions. He questions the purpose of female sports categories if not for the biological differences between men and women. In response, one woman proposes the removal of sex-based sports categories—even if this results in natal men outperforming natal women.

Common Ground Conversations https://commongroundconversations.co/

Chapters
0:00 Intro
1:05 Claim: “Gender is different than sex.”
8:12 Claim 2: “Sex is assigned at birth.”
9:00 Claim 3: “One can change their sex.”
16:00 Differences in definition of biological sex
20:25 Gender vs gender identity vs sex
24:15 Testing if someone is M or F
29:00 Interruption
30:20 Conversation continues
32:00 Can you identify out of your sex?
36:00 Should biological spaces be respected?
40:25 Disconfirmation