The Lost Moment (1947) | Directed by Martin Gabel

"The Lost Moment" is a 1947 psychological thriller film directed by Martin Gabel in his only directorial effort. The movie is an adaptation of Henry James' novella "The Aspern Papers" and is set in a hauntingly atmospheric Venice. It blends elements of romance, drama, and mystery, fitting into the broader categories of film noir and Gothic romance.

In "The Lost Moment," Robert Cummings plays Lewis Venable, an ambitious American publisher who travels to Venice in search of the love letters of a famous deceased poet, Jeffrey Ashton. Venable disguises himself as a writer to gain access to a decrepit, eerie palazzo owned by Juliana Bordereau, played by Agnes Moorehead. Juliana is the elderly lover of the late poet and possesses the coveted letters. Venable attempts to charm Juliana's niece, Tina, portrayed by Susan Hayward, to get closer to the letters. As the plot unfolds, secrets are slowly revealed, leading to unexpected psychological depths and complexities, including Tina's strange belief that she is the reincarnation of the poet's lover.

"The Lost Moment" is ambitious in its psychological and thematic depth, attempting to explore issues of obsession, identity, and the haunting power of the past. However, the film is often criticized for its somewhat convoluted plot and the overly melodramatic execution, which may detract from its coherence and emotional impact. While the setting of Venice is effectively moody and Gothic, lending a unique atmosphere to the film, the storytelling sometimes struggles to maintain a consistent tone.

Robert Cummings delivers a capable performance, though his character's motivations may feel somewhat opaque due to the script's complexities. Agnes Moorehead provides a standout performance, embodying her character with a haunting presence that enhances the film's Gothic overtones. Susan Hayward is also compelling, adding to the film's tense and mysterious ambiance. The cinematography is notably striking, using shadows and light effectively to create a sense of suspense and foreboding, which are hallmarks of film noir.

Robert Cummings as Lewis Venable
Susan Hayward as Tina Bordereau
Agnes Moorehead as Juliana Bordereau
Eduardo Ciannelli as Father Rinaldo
ohn Archer as Charles Russell

"The Lost Moment" is a film that might appeal to fans of Gothic literature and those interested in psychological narratives set against the backdrop of film noir. While it may not be as tightly executed as some other classics from the era, its ambitious blend of romance, mystery, and psychological drama provides a compelling reason to watch, especially for those drawn to moody, atmospheric settings and complex character studies.