On Approval (1944) | Directed by and starring Clive Brook

"On Approval" is a 1944 British comedy film directed by and starring Clive Brook. The film is an adaptation of the 1926 play by Frederick Lonsdale. Set in the 1890s, it follows the humorous escapades of two wealthy, yet eccentric, couples. The story centers around Maria Wislack, a wealthy widow, and her friend, Helen Hale, who decide to test their suitors' compatibility by taking them on a trial period 'on approval' at Maria's Scottish island estate. The suitors, Richard Halton and George, Lord Dalroy, face a series of comedic misadventures and romantic entanglements as they try to prove themselves worthy.

- Clive Brook as George, Duke of Bristol
- Beatrice Lillie as Maria Wislack
- Googie Withers as Helen Hale
- Roland Culver as Richard Halton

"On Approval" is a sophisticated and witty comedy that captures the essence of British humor and high society manners. Clive Brook's direction maintains a light, breezy pace, while his dual role as director and lead actor showcases his versatility and talent. The film’s screenplay is filled with sharp, clever dialogue that brings out the humorous aspects of the characters' interactions and predicaments.

Beatrice Lillie delivers a standout performance as Maria Wislack, bringing her signature comedic timing and charm to the role. Her chemistry with Clive Brook and the rest of the cast adds depth and humor to the narrative. Googie Withers and Roland Culver provide strong supporting performances, adding to the film's overall appeal. The elegant costumes and settings enhance the period atmosphere, making the film a visual delight.

Upon its release, "On Approval" received positive reviews from critics who praised its wit, charm, and performances. Critics appreciated the film’s adherence to the spirit of Frederick Lonsdale's original play while adding a cinematic flair. Beatrice Lillie's performance was particularly lauded for its comedic brilliance, with many considering it one of her best screen roles. Clive Brook's direction and his portrayal of George were also well-received, highlighting his ability to balance humor with a touch of sophistication.

The film was recognized for its smart and entertaining script, which effectively brought out the humor and eccentricities of the characters. The interplay between the lead actors and their comedic timing was highlighted as a major strength of the film.

In modern retrospectives, "On Approval" is celebrated as a classic British comedy. Contemporary critics and film historians appreciate its witty dialogue, strong performances, and the way it captures the social mores of the time. The film remains a delightful example of mid-20th-century British cinema, showcasing the comedic talents of its cast and the adept direction of Clive Brook. It continues to be enjoyed by audiences for its humor, charm, and timeless appeal.