Andrew Holowchak - Why Scholars want to destroy Thomas Jefferson

On May 10, 2025, the historic Hanover Tavern in Hanover County, Virginia, hosted an engaging event titled "Un-Canceling Jefferson," organized by the Virginia Council and led by the passionate Ann McLean. The event featured a compelling presentation by Dr. M. Andrew Holowchak, a distinguished Jefferson scholar with over 70 books and 375 essays to his name, including 28 dedicated to Thomas Jefferson. Holowchak’s talk dives into the heart of Jefferson’s legacy, challenging modern narratives that he argues distort the Founding Father’s contributions with ideologically driven claims. His dynamic delivery and sharp wit make this presentation a must-watch for anyone intrigued by history, liberty, and the battle over how we remember our nation’s founders.

Holowchak’s presentation is a spirited defense of Jefferson, particularly against allegations surrounding his relationship with Sally Hemings and his views on race. With a philosopher’s precision and a historian’s depth, he dismantles what he sees as weak evidence behind these claims, pointing to the 2018 discovery of Hemings’ bedroom at Monticello as a financially motivated move rather than a historical breakthrough. He shares personal anecdotes of being ostracized by institutions like Monticello for his contrarian views, adding a layer of intrigue that draws viewers into the high stakes of historical scholarship. His call for fact-based history, inspired by Leopold von Ranke’s pursuit of truth, resonates as a rallying cry for open discussion, making this talk both intellectually stimulating and emotionally charged.

The presentation also critiques the post-modernist approaches of historians like Peter Onuf and Annette Gordon-Reed, whom Holowchak accuses of prioritizing narrative over evidence. His lively critique, peppered with humor and sharp analogies, keeps the audience engaged while underscoring the importance of rigorous historical methods. Holowchak’s passion for Jefferson’s vision of liberty shines through, inviting viewers to reconsider the complexities of a man who shaped America’s ideals. Paired with insights from fellow speaker Robert F. Turner, a noted Jefferson defender, this talk promises to spark curiosity and debate, making it essential viewing for history buffs and anyone eager to explore the clash between past and present.