Robert Turner - The Jefferson-Hemmings Scholars Commission Findings

At the "Un-Canceling Jefferson" event held at the historic Hanover Tavern in Hanover County, Virginia, on May 20, 2025, Robert F. Turner, a distinguished legal scholar and former professor at the University of Virginia, delivered a captivating defense of Thomas Jefferson’s legacy. Hosted by Ann McLean of the Virginia Council, the event featured presentations by Bill Byrd, Dr. M. Andrew Holowchak, and Turner, all aimed at countering modern criticisms of Jefferson. Turner’s talk, in particular, stands out for its rigorous scholarship and compelling narrative, making it a must-watch for anyone intrigued by American history and the complexities of its Founding Fathers.

Turner begins by tackling the Jefferson-Hemings controversy, challenging the claim that Jefferson fathered Sally Hemings’ children. As chair of the Jefferson-Hemings Scholars Commission, he cites its 400-page report, with 1,400 footnotes, which concluded with near-unanimous skepticism about Jefferson’s paternity. He clarifies that the 1998 DNA study only showed a Jefferson male could have been the father, not specifically Thomas, and points to Randolph Jefferson, Thomas’s younger brother, as a more likely candidate, supported by historical records and family accounts. Turner’s engaging delivery, laced with humor, keeps the audience captivated while addressing serious issues of historical accuracy.

The presentation also critiques modern historians like Annette Gordon-Reed, whom Turner accuses of altering historical documents to fit their narrative, providing specific examples that highlight academic integrity concerns. He shares dramatic anecdotes, such as Monticello’s attempt to overshadow the commission’s press conference with a White House event, which backfired and amplified their findings. Turner’s talk is a passionate call for fact-based history, echoing Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s message of judging character over skin color, and challenges sensationalized narratives that obscure Jefferson’s contributions. For history enthusiasts and those curious about historical controversies, this presentation is a thrilling blend of scholarship and storytelling, inviting viewers to rethink Jefferson’s legacy.