Premium Only Content
*** IMPORTANT *** The President Swears In 250 Troops In Washington DC - JUSTICE IS COMING
Thank you for watching ⚡⭐⚡
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OATH OF OFFICE, OATH OF ENLISTMENT
Marine Corps Base Quantico -- Warrant Officer Hugh Thompson willingly disobeyed a commander’s orders and even threatened to open fire on American troops when he saved the lives of at least 10 Vietnamese civilians during the My Lai Massacre. Not only was Thompson never punished for disobeying orders, but he was later awarded the Soldier’s Medal for his courageous actions.
If the orders given that day had been lawful he could have faced court martial or even charges of treason under the Uniform Code of Military Justice.
The My Lai Massacre was not the first or the last time a military force would be misused or corrupted. This type of power abuse is what the UCMJ and Oath of Office were designed to prevent and also what allowed Thompson to do the right thing without punishment.
There is an important difference to understand when reading the Officers' Oath of Enlistment compared to the Oath of Office.
• Both officers and enlisted service members swear to support and defend the Constitution of the United States,but in the Oath of Enlistment, service members swear they will “obey the orders of the president of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over [them], according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice.”
•Officers do not include this in their Oath of Office.
•Instead, they swear to support and defend the constitution and “well and faithfully discharge the duties of [their] office.”
•Why are the two oaths different and what does it mean that officers do not swear obedience to the president or higher ranking officers?
This concept traces back to the intentions of the Founding Fathers who created our governing system with a separation of powers and series of checks and balances between the three branches.This ensures no single branch or person gains too much power and becomes corrupted.
• By swearing allegiance to a set of ideals and laws, our military is not bound by the orders of a single person, but are dedicated to the defense of the people and their way of life.
Despite disobeying orders and even threatening to open fire on American troops, Thompson’s actions prevented further war crimes and defended the lives of noncombatants in Vietnam.This is the purpose behind the Oath of Office allowing for the disobedience to unlawful orders.
The obligation and responsibility to act against unlawful orders is not exclusive to officers. Article 90 of the UCMJ statesthat service members are only obligated to obey lawful orders. This gives authority to small unit leaders and even riflemen to use their judgment to serve honorably and disobey orders when they do not uphold the moral standards of our service. Not only does this act as a safeguard to corruption and abuse of power, but it also develops a sense of responsibility and leadership at all levels of command.
If this is the case, however, then why is the distinction made between the two oaths when both enlisted and officers are not obligated to follow unlawful orders according to the UCMJ?
• Officers, especially at higher ranks, have a unique position of authority and influence within the organization that could be taken advantage of for political gain.Swearing loyalty to the Constitution instead of the president or any other person means that officials cannot manipulate officers in order to gain control over the military and become dictators.
• The intent is to ensure our military fights in defense of the people and their way of life instead of being misused for political gain.Article 90 of the UCMJ allows for legal disobedience of unlawful orders for both enlisted and officers.
The officer’s oath acts as another safeguard against power corruptionby not swearing obedience to the president or other officials, but rather to the Constitution. As a result of these two, our military is capable of having people like Thompson, who can correct situations where the military is being misused without fear of punishment for their actions.
Giving the individual Marine responsibility for judging orders as right or wrong keeps our service members accountable and helps keeps our honor clean as a professional warfighting organization.
_____________________________________________
I'm sorry I've been missing in action for the past month, I fell and snapped both bones in my ankle. I just got out of 20 days locked in rehab. I'm back now even though I'm still in a wheelchair, and would appreciate all you can do to share my videos. I love you guys...
If you enjoy my Channel, Please LIKE and SHARE the Videos.
https://buymeacoffee.com/bruceafigert
Fair Use Disclaimer:
The following news content may contain copyrighted material. In accordance with the principles of fair use, this material is distributed without profit for educational and informational purposes. The use of copyrighted material is done solely for the purpose of commentary, criticism, reporting, and teaching. Such use is believed to be transformative and in good faith, and it adheres to the limitations set forth in copyright law. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes that exceed fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
-
21:57
GritsGG
14 hours agoHigh Kill Quad Dub & Win Streaking! Most Winning CoD Player of All Time!
5.53K -
5:44
SpartakusLIVE
17 hours agoARC BOUNTY HUNTER #arcraiders
10K2 -
15:50
MetatronCore
2 days agoMy Statement on Charlie Kirk's Shooting
7.73K6 -
LIVE
Lofi Girl
2 years agoSynthwave Radio 🌌 - beats to chill/game to
752 watching -
3:31:12
Price of Reason
13 hours agoThanksgiving Special - Is Stranger Things 5 any good and other SURPRISES!
113K1 -
14:14
Robbi On The Record
8 hours ago $4.77 earnedThe Identity Crisis No One Wants to Admit | Identity VS. Personality
18.2K3 -
31:10
The Why Files
4 days agoThe First Earth Battalion: America's Strangest Military Experiment
61.4K27 -
4:18:02
SpartakusLIVE
9 hours ago#1 Pilgrim of PAIN Gives Thanks HAPPILY as he DESTROYS Enemies and BAGS LOOT
176K7 -
59:47
iCkEdMeL
10 hours ago $43.54 earnedBREAKING: National Guard Soldier Dies + New Video Shows Suspect Opening Fire
36.3K39 -
1:20:38
Flyover Conservatives
1 day agoThanksgiving’s Hidden History: Islamic Pirates, Spanish Threats, and Socialism - Bill Federer | FOC Show
43.7K3