Episode 3191: The Collapse of Hierarchy: The Ruin of the Modern Catholic Church

www.catholic-reboot.com

Nightly Zoom Coordinates for Rosary:
Meeting ID: 865 8978 0399
Passcode: Wjjv4960!
Speak Lord for your Servant is Listening
Book Recommendation of the Day
Not on Sunday
The Ruin of the Modern Church: The Collapse of Hierarchy
The Visible Ruins of the Church
Welcome to today’s episode. Many Catholics today sense that something is deeply wrong in the Church. Confusion abounds: parishes are closing, vocations are dwindling, Catholics are unsure of what the Church even teaches on issues once crystal clear. And at the heart of this crisis lies the collapse of the Church’s divinely instituted hierarchy.
Christ established His Church with order, clarity, and authority but in the modern Church, hierarchy has been flattened, priesthood diminished, bishops weakened, and the pope often treated as a figurehead manipulated by committees and bureaucrats. In this episode, we will trace how this destruction of hierarchy has led to the ruin of the modern Catholic Church, why it matters, and how restoration must begin.
Christ Established a Hierarchical Church
From the very beginning, the Church was not a loose association of believers. It was established by Christ as a visible, hierarchical society.
• In Matthew 16:18–19, Christ says to Peter: “Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build My Church… I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven.” The “keys” symbolize authority, governance, and succession.
• In John 21:15–17, Christ commands Peter to feed His lambs and tend His sheep, making him the shepherd over the entire flock.
• The Apostles were ordained as bishops and sent out, with power to teach, sanctify, and govern.
The early Fathers confirm this:
• St. Ignatius of Antioch (d. 107) wrote: “Where the bishop is, there is the Catholic Church.” He insisted that no Eucharist could be valid without the bishop or his delegate.
• St. Cyprian of Carthage (d. 258) famously said: “He cannot have God as Father who does not have the Church as Mother.” And this Church, he taught, is bound together by the unity of the bishop.
The Council of Trent later reaffirmed: hierarchy is not optional it is divinely instituted. The Church is neither a democracy nor a federation of autonomous congregations.
Hierarchy, in Catholic understanding, is not about power for its own sake but about order and fatherhood. Just as God is a Father, and the family has a father as head, so too the Mystical Body of Christ is ordered under visible shepherds.
The Modern Attack on Hierarchy
Fast-forward to the modern era. Beginning, especially in the 20th century, the Church began to absorb worldly notions of democracy and equality. The Second Vatican Council, while not abolishing hierarchy on paper, in practice opened the door for collegiality and democratization to undermine the traditional order.

Bishops’ Conferences: These became bureaucratic super-structures where individual bishops no longer act as successors of the Apostles with direct responsibility for their flock, but rather as voting members of national committees. St. John Fisher, who stood alone against Henry VIII, would today be silenced by a “conference consensus.”
Parish Councils and Committees: Authority in parishes shifted from the priest to councils often dominated by laity with little understanding of Catholic doctrine. Liturgical committees “design” Masses. Finance committees dictate parish direction. The shepherd became a hired administrator.
Flattening of the Priesthood
The very language changed. Priests became “presiders” instead of sacrificers. Religious sisters and lay ministers took over once-sacred roles at the altar, confusing the faithful as to the distinct sacramental power of Holy Orders.
Pope Pius X foresaw this danger in Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907), where he condemned Modernists for trying to reduce the Church to a mere human society shaped by democratic ideals. He said: “The Church is essentially an unequal society; it is composed of two categories of persons, the Pastors and the flock. So distinct are these categories that only in the Pastors resides the right and authority to rule and direct.”
Modernism sought to erase this distinction and the results are visible everywhere.
The Fruits of Destroyed Authority
The collapse of hierarchy has produced bitter fruit:
1. Doctrinal Confusion:
o Catholics in one diocese hear teaching on contraception, homosexuality, or interfaith dialogue that directly contradicts what is taught in another diocese.
o The laity no longer know whom to trust, because shepherds abdicate their teaching office. As Pope Leo XIII warned in Satis Cognitum: “To reject the authority of the Church is to reject Christ Himself.”

2. Liturgical Anarchy:
o The Mass, once the bedrock of unity, became fragmented. “Clown Masses,” “Youth Masses,” and endless innovations reduced the sacred liturgy to a community performance.
o Without priestly authority, worship was remade according to committees and “preferences.” The result: declining reverence, loss of belief in the Real Presence, and empty churches.
3. Moral Collapse:
o Without strong hierarchical teaching, Catholics embrace secular morality. Divorce, contraception, abortion, same-sex unions all find justification from priests and bishops who refuse to teach firmly.
o When the shepherds scatter, the wolves devour the flock.
4. Loss of Vocations:
o The priesthood, stripped of its sacred authority, no longer attracts men willing to sacrifice. Seminaries shrink, while traditional orders faithful to hierarchy flourish.
o Where hierarchy is upheld, vocations thrive; where hierarchy is denied, the Church withers.
Christ warned: “A house divided against itself cannot stand” (Mark 3:25). The modern Church, having undermined its own structure, is crumbling before our eyes.
Segment 4: The True Nature of Authority
It is crucial to understand that true Catholic hierarchy is not tyranny. Authority in the Church is patterned after Christ Himself.
• In John 13, Christ washed the feet of the Apostles. The Pope, bishops, and priests are called to serve. But service does not mean surrendering authority; rather, it means exercising authority as true fathers.
• St. Paul in Ephesians 5 compared Christ’s headship over the Church to the husband’s headship over his wife. This is not domination, but sacrificial love.
The saints constantly defended authority:
• St. Catherine of Siena, though unafraid to rebuke popes, always upheld papal primacy. She called the pope “the sweet Christ on earth.”
• St. Robert Bellarmine wrote: “The supreme authority of the Church is necessary to preserve unity, just as the supreme head is necessary to preserve the unity of a body.”
When authority is despised, chaos follows. True freedom in the Church flows from obedience to God-given authority, not rebellion against it.
The Path to Restoration
How can the Church recover? Only by re-establishing hierarchy as Christ intended:
1. Reverence for the Priesthood:
o Priests must once again be seen as Alter Christus another Christ not social workers or entertainers.
o Laity should support priests with obedience and prayer, not undermine them with demands for power.
2. Strong Bishops:
o Bishops must reclaim their apostolic authority instead of hiding behind conferences or bureaucracies.
o Like St. Athanasius against Arianism, a bishop must be willing to stand alone against the world if truth requires it.
3. Faithful Laity:
o The laity’s role is essential, but it is not to usurp the priesthood. Vatican II’s true teaching on the “universal call to holiness” must be rightly understood: holiness in the family, the workplace, and the world not taking the sanctuary.
4. Return to Tradition:
o Where hierarchy is preserved in traditional parishes, Latin Mass communities, and traditional seminaries faith is alive. These communities, often mocked by the world, are the seeds of renewal.
o The restoration of the liturgy and hierarchy go hand in hand, because the Mass is the visible expression of the Church’s hierarchical order.

Conclusion
The ruination of the modern Church comes from the destruction of her hierarchy. When shepherds abdicate, the sheep scatter. But Christ’s plan has not failed. His promises remain: “I am with you all days, even to the consummation of the world.”
The crisis we see is not the collapse of Christ’s Church which is indefectible but the collapse of men who betrayed their mission. Renewal will come when we embrace again the visible order Christ gave: pope, bishops, priests, and laity, each fulfilling their vocation under God’s will.
“Grace That Opens Our Lips: St. Paul, the Deaf-Mute, and St. Bartholomew”
________________________________________
Introduction
My dear friends in Christ, welcome to today’s reflection. It is Sunday, August 24th, 2025, the 11th Sunday after Pentecost, and also the Feast of St. Bartholomew the Apostle.
Today’s Scripture readings unite two powerful themes: the transforming grace of God and the healing power of Christ. St. Paul, in the Epistle, confesses that all he is comes from grace. And in the Gospel, Christ heals a deaf-mute man, opening his ears to hear and his tongue to speak rightly.
These truths shine brilliantly in the life of St. Bartholomew, who was transformed by Christ’s call and became an Apostle and martyr, proclaiming the Gospel even to the ends of the earth.
________________________________________
Epistle – 1 Corinthians 15:1–10
St. Paul recalls the Gospel he preached—the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ. He insists this is no invention, but tradition received and handed down. Paul describes himself as “the least of the apostles,” unworthy because he once persecuted the Church. Yet he boldly declares: “By the grace of God, I am what I am; and His grace in me hath not been void.”
Reflection
This passage highlights two essentials of Catholic faith:
1. The centrality of the Resurrection: Our faith is not moralism, but the proclamation of Christ risen from the dead.
2. The primacy of grace: Paul reminds us that all holiness, all transformation, all apostolic success comes not from human effort but from God’s grace.
For traditional Catholics today, this is a needed reminder. The Church is in crisis; we feel small, despised, sometimes powerless. Yet if we remain faithful, grace will not be void. God can transform us, as He transformed Paul, into instruments of His truth.
________________________________________
Gospel – Mark 7:31–37
Our Lord encounters a man who is deaf and mute. Leading him aside, Jesus puts His fingers into the man’s ears, touches his tongue, and says, “Ephpheta—that is, Be opened.” Immediately, the man’s ears are opened and his tongue is loosed, and he speaks plainly.
Reflection
The healing of the deaf-mute is more than physical—it is spiritual symbolism. Deafness represents the soul closed to God’s word. Mutism represents the inability to proclaim His truth. Only Christ can open ears to hear and loosen tongues to speak rightly.
This miracle recalls our baptismal rite, where the priest prays the Ephpheta prayer, asking God to open our ears and mouths for faith. Today’s Gospel reminds us that our Catholic identity is this: to hear God’s Word in purity, and to proclaim it without compromise.
In an age where many Catholics no longer hear sound doctrine and where the faithful are often silenced, this Gospel calls us to pray for Christ’s touch: that our ears remain open to Tradition and our tongues proclaim the fullness of the faith.
________________________________________
Feast of St. Bartholomew
Today we honor St. Bartholomew the Apostle, also known as Nathanael. When he first encountered Christ, Our Lord declared, “Behold, a true Israelite in whom there is no guile.” Tradition tells us Bartholomew preached as far as India and Armenia, where he was martyred—flayed alive—for the Gospel.
His life embodies both the Epistle and Gospel:
• Like Paul, he was transformed entirely by grace, called from obscurity to apostolic glory.
• Like the healed man in the Gospel, his ears were opened to recognize Christ and his tongue loosed to proclaim Him to the nations.
St. Bartholomew reminds us that fidelity often costs dearly, but grace makes us steadfast unto the end.
________________________________________
Application for Today
• Acknowledge grace: Like Paul, confess that without grace we are nothing, but with grace all things are possible.
• Open ears and mouths: Pray for fidelity to hear God’s word in its fullness, and courage to speak it in a world that prefers silence.
• Imitate the Apostles: Live with simplicity and courage, willing to be despised if it means fidelity to Christ.
• Prepare for witness: Remember that martyrdom, whether red or white, is the crown of Christian life.
________________________________________
Conclusionary Prayer
O Lord, who didst call St. Bartholomew from obscurity to apostolic glory, grant that through his prayers we may hear Thy word with faithful ears and proclaim Thy truth with fearless tongues. By Thy grace, may we be transformed, as St. Paul was, into vessels of Thy mercy. Open our hearts, our ears, and our lips, that we may bear witness to Thy Resurrection until our final breath. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
St. Bartholomew the Apostle, pray for us.
Sacred Heart of Jesus, have mercy on us.
Immaculate Heart of Mary, intercede for us.