The Unsolved Mystery of Who Killed Albert Anastasia

On October 25, 1957, Mafia boss Albert Anastasia was gunned down in a Manhattan barbershop—but the two men who pulled the triggers were just puppets in a larger conspiracy. This documentary uncovers the hidden truth behind the most perfectly orchestrated mob hit in history, where every suspect had motive and every alibi concealed deeper secrets.

From Carlo Gambino's calculated betrayal to the mysterious Sicilian hit squad that vanished without a trace, we reveal how the Lord High Executioner of Murder Inc. met his end in the most ordinary of places. Based on declassified FBI files and witness testimonies, this investigation exposes the web of conspiracies that led to that fatal morning at the Park Sheraton Hotel.

Who really ordered the hit—was it Gambino's ambition or Genovese's greed? Why did Anastasia dismiss his bodyguards that morning, and could he have known death was coming?

Share your theory: Were the infamous Gallo brothers the real triggermen, or did the killers truly vanish back to Sicily?

🔔 Subscribe for more unsolved mysteries from organized crime's darkest chapters
📺 Next: The Lufthansa Heist—The $6 Million Crime That Inspired Goodfellas