Col Douglas Macgregor: Taming the Warfare State

Col Douglas Macgregor: Taming the Warfare State

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlwOq4Qs1oQ

Warfare and technology have changed: large forward-deployed forces and naval squadrons are now vulnerable and can be rapidly destroyed in a high-end conflict.

The top priority should be defending the Western Hemisphere and U.S. territory; large-scale overseas expeditionary assaults (moving hundreds of thousands of troops) are effectively obsolete.

Scale back unnecessary overseas bases (the ~800 count) and shift to a mix of defense and diplomacy — even engaging adversaries or sanctioned states pragmatically to avoid conflict.

Five pillars for a new national military strategy:

Defend America first (protect borders, coastal waters, airspace; avoid force unless directly attacked).

Preserve core capabilities to maintain freedom of action, with a reduced set of overseas bases for critical lines of communication.

Declare a no-first-use nuclear doctrine while retaining deterrent industrial capacity.

Create a national operational defense staff and a powerful, accountable chief of defense; move to merit- and exam-based promotion/selection.

Build new 21st-century forces through protected experimentation rather than incremental retrofitting of old structures.

Investment priorities should shift toward ISR (intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance) from seabed to space, long/medium-range strike, and integrated air defenses for North America; maneuver (ground forces) should operate under the ISR-strike umbrella rather than as massed formations.

The Russia–Ukraine fighting validates the ISR-strike model: assembled forces are exposed to relentless surveillance and strikes, and AI/robotics will accelerate that trend.

Institutional resistance (“presentism” / service-centric conservatism) must be managed so experimentation can produce real, lasting change.