Band of Brothers MOST HATED in Normandy 1944 Then and Now

He trained Easy Company. He was despised by many. But he jumped into Normandy on D-Day — not as their leader, but still in uniform as a member of the famed 506th PIR.

In this WW2 Wayfinder “Then and Now” episode, we follow the trail of Captain Herbert Sobel, the often-misunderstood original commander of Easy Company, 506th PIR, 101st Airborne Division. Made infamous by Band of Brothers, Sobel is remembered for his harsh leadership at Camp Toccoa, the relentless “Currahee” runs, and the deep resentment felt by those under his command — particularly Lt Winters.

But there’s more to the story.

We explore a rare wartime moment: Captain Sobel in Carentan, just days after D-Day, captured in photos briefing General Maxwell Taylor, commander of the 101st Airborne, in his role as the 506th’s regimental S4 officer. In this episode, we revisit that very location — blending archival images and modern footage — to piece together the overlooked part of Sobel’s journey in Normandy.

Though sidelined before the jump into France on D-Day, Sobel didn’t fade into obscurity. He continued to serve during the Korean War, eventually reaching the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. His life ended in tragedy, but not without dedication to the uniform he once wore with pride.

This episode offers a more nuanced look at a figure many have written off. Not a defence. Not a condemnation. Just the facts — as they happened.