1 month ago

Marine Insurer May Dispose of Vessel to Avoid Waste
Post 5249

In Western World Insurance Company v. The Estate Of Shawn Arsenault, No. 25-cv-13413-PGL, United States District Court, D. Massachusetts (December 17, 2025) the USDC was asked to resolve a marine insurance dispute after the sinking of the F/V Seahorse, a commercial fishing vessel, off Cape Cod on June 8, 2025. The vessel’s owner and operator, Shawn Arsenault, died in the incident.

Western World Insurance Company issued a hull insurance policy for the vessel. With no personal representative yet appointed for the estate, the insurer cannot determine the proper payee for the insurance proceeds.

The insurer paid for the vessel’s recovery and removal, and the vessel is now with a salvage company, incurring substantial storage fees. The insurer determined the loss is covered under the policy.

LEGAL ISSUES AND COURT’S ANALYSIS

The insurer sought three forms of preliminary relief:

Permission for its counsel to hold the insurance proceeds in trust (IOLTA account) for the estate.
Authorization to deduct $1,701 from the proceeds for an unpaid premium.
Permission to dispose of the wrecked vessel to stop further storage fees.
COURT’S RULINGS
Insurance Proceeds:

The court allowed the insurer’s counsel to temporarily hold the insurance proceeds in trust, ensuring they remain available for the rightful recipient once determined.

Unpaid Premium Deduction:

The court denied the request to deduct the unpaid premium at this time, citing lack of urgency and insufficient documentation. This issue can be addressed after a personal representative is appointed.

Disposal of Vessel:

The court permitted the insurer to dispose of the vessel, finding that further delay would result in unnecessary waste due to mounting storage fees and lack of salvage value.

KEY LEGAL TAKEAWAYS

With the policy proceeds secured in the IOLTA account of Plaintiff's counsel, there is no serious risk that the monies will be lost or diverted. For that reason the court balanced the urgency of stopping storage fees against the need to protect estate assets and ensure proper distribution of insurance proceeds. Temporary custodianship of insurance funds by counsel was found to be appropriate pending probate.

The USDC concluded that disposal of insured property may be authorized to prevent waste when estate administration is delayed.

ZALMA OPINION

On rare occasions courts reach a decision based on what is fair and apply common sense to a legal dispute. The vessel was recovered by the insurer and stored it while the insured's estate does nothing to appoint a representative to take the claims payments and make a decision with regard to the salvage. Since it makes no sense to leave the damaged vessel in storage and to make the insurer work in probate court to learn who to pay, like Solomon Judge Paul G. Levenson allowed the Plaintiff's lawyer to hold the money owed in his trust account for the estate and dispose of the vessel to stop the waste of payment of storage fees.

Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.

Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe

Go to X @bzalma; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the InsuranceClaims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk.

Loading comments...