Why Rob Liefeld Is Wrong (But Right) About The X-Men

Rob Liefeld says the X-Men are failing because they aren't "macho" anymore. He's wrong.

The X-Men aren't suffering from a lack of macho characters. They're suffering from a catastrophic structural failure in storytelling.

In this deep-dive analysis, we expose how Marvel Comics editors have systematically abandoned one of the five universal rules of narrative, fundamentally changing the appeal of their flagship titles. We show the disastrous shift from Male-Coded Goals (external, task-oriented conquest) to Female-Coded Goals (internal, introspective discovery), and why this change is driving reader apathy and killing sales.

We analyze the Claremont Mandate to prove what made the X-Men successful and reveal the shockingly simple fix: The Editorial Goal Mandate, a non-negotiable checklist that could bring structure, high-stakes, and the traditional young male audience back to Marvel Comics.

Don't forget to Like, Subscribe, and hit the Bell for notifications for more deep comic analysis!

Get The Revelation Cycle today!👉 https://amzn.to/4pnN2LL

Read my FREE Urban Fantasy Adventures👉 https://mysticstreets.substack.com

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀 https://vidiq.com/ComicalOpinions

0:00 - Intro
1:01 - Apathy & Liefeld's Rant
3:14 - Your Experience?
3:45 - The Misused Story Element
8:10 - The Claremont Run
9:53 - Today's X-Men
11:35 - Liefeld Is Right (Sort Of)
12:48 - The Fix
15:53 - Final Thoughts

===========================================
Subscribe to our newsletter to read more comic reviews and analysis every week.
===========================================
Subscribe now👉 https://comicalopinions.com/subscribe

===========================================
Subscribe to our Podcast to listen along on your commute to work
===========================================

Youtube: @comicalopinions
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5lndyl8...
Stitcher: https://www.pandora.com/podcast/comic...
Audible: https://www.audible.com/pd/Comical-Op...

===========================================
Connect with Comical Opinions on your favorite social media platform
===========================================

✔️YouTube: / @comicalopinions
✔️Twitter: / comicalopinions
✔️Facebook: / comicalopinions
✔️Instagram: / comicalopinions
✔️TikTok: / comicalopinions

Intro music: https://www.fesliyanstudios.com/royal...
Outro music: https://www.fesliyanstudios.com/royal...

Disclaimer: This video/podcast is not sponsored. Some product links are affiliate links, which means we'll receive a small commission from anything you buy. Thank you for your support.